Long John Silver’s Secret Menu [Updated April 2024]

Welcome to the Long John Silver’s Secret Menu!

Bored with the usual at Long John Silver’s? Forget searching for a secret menu! This guide will show you how to create exciting new meals using their existing menu items.

We’ll share some clever combinations and add-ons to make your next Long John Silver’s visit a real adventure!

Long John Silver's Secret Menu

Long John Silver’s Secret Menu with Prices

There isn’t an official “secret menu” at Long John Silver’s, there are some hidden gems and hacks you can use to craft your delicious pirate feast.

  1. Wild Alaskan Pollock Sandwich
  2. Grilled Shrimp Tacos
  3. Grilled Salmon Meal
  4. Fried Clams
  5. Extra Crumblies
  6. Surf and Turf Sliders
  7. Double-Battered Fish
  8. Grilled Shrimp and Battered Chicken Platter
  9. Cinnamon Sugar Hushpuppies
  10. Free Chicken or Fish on “Talk Like a Pirate Day”

Wild Alaskan Pollock Sandwich

Long John Silver's Secret Menu

You can add a spicy kick to your Wild Alaska Pollock Sandwich by asking for Baja sauce instead of the usual tartar sauce.

Baja sauce is a creamy sauce with a bit of a kick, thanks to ingredients like sriracha and lime juice. It pairs well with the fish and complements the pickles nicely.

Grilled Shrimp Tacos

Long John Silver's Secret Menu

Ditch the Baja sauce! Baja sauce can be loaded with sugar and calories. The natural flavor of the grilled shrimp shines through without it, and you can still enjoy a light and flavorful taco.

To add more excitement to your healthy taco, consider ordering a side of steamed veggies like corn or green beans for some extra crunch and nutrients.

Grilled Salmon Meal

Long John Silver's Secret Menu

Here’s a secret menu hack for Long John Silver’s! While their menu doesn’t offer a spicy option for the grilled salmon meal itself, you can ask for chili sauce on the side.

This is because Long John Silver’s offers different sauces for their grilled items like rice bowls and tacos, including a Sweet Chili sauce.

Fried Clams

Long John Silver's Secret Menu

Not all Long John Silver’s locations offer fried clams. It’s a good idea to call your nearest restaurant to see if they have them on the menu before you head out specifically for them.

Fried clams can be a delicious choice for an appetizer if you find a location that serves them. These bite-sized treats are typically dipped in batter, fried crispy, and served with tartar sauce for a delightful combination of salty, savory, and tangy flavors.

Extra Crumblies

Long John Silver's Secret Menu

Long John Silver’s has a hidden gem on their menu for fans of crispy, salty snacks: Crumblies! These complimentary delights are the leftover crispy bits of batter from their fried fish and chicken.

They’re a delicious and addictive secret menu item. Next time you visit Long John Silver’s, ask for extra Crumblies on the side.

Surf and Turf Sliders

Long John Silver's Secret Menu

Calling all fans of both KFC and Long John Silver’s! Here’s a delicious hack to create the ultimate surf and turf sliders at home. Next time you find yourself near a location with both restaurants nearby, consider this:

  • Order a Fish and Chicken Meal from Long John Silver’s.
  • Grab a side of biscuits from KFC.

Voila! You have all the ingredients for delicious homemade surf and turf sliders. Just take your favorite flaky fish from Long John Silver’s and pair it with a piece of juicy KFC chicken on a fluffy KFC biscuit.

Double-Battered Fish

Long John Silver's Secret Menu

Long John Silver’s locations will double-batter your fish (or any other fried item) upon request. This means an extra layer of crispy coating for an even more satisfying textural experience.

Next time you’re at Long John Silver’s and craving some extra crunch, politely ask if they can double-batter your fish.

Grilled Shrimp and Battered Chicken Platter

Long John Silver's Secret Menu

Craving both crispy chicken and juicy grilled shrimp from Long John Silver’s? You don’t have to settle for just one! Here’s a handy tip for creating your custom surf and turf platter:

  • Look at the menu for existing variety platters, like the Grilled Shrimp and Salmon Variety Platter.
  • Politely ask if they can substitute the salmon with crispy battered chicken. Most locations will be happy to customize your order within reason.

Cinnamon Sugar Hushpuppies

Craving a sweet and savory treat? Long John Silver’s hushpuppies are delicious golden nuggets on their own, but did you know you can unlock a secret menu option at some locations?

Ask if they can dust your hushpuppies with cinnamon sugar! This hack is particularly common at combo locations that share space with Taco Bell.pen_spark

Free Chicken or Fish on “Talk Like a Pirate Day”

Calling all pirate wannabes! Mark your calendars for September 19th, International Talk Like a Pirate Day! Long John Silver’s goes all out to celebrate this fun holiday. Landlubbers who can speak like a true pirate get rewarded with free booty (well, free food)! In 2022, they offered:

  • A free piece of fish or chicken for anyone who could articulate their order in pirate lingo.
  • A free two-piece fish or chicken basket for the hearties who went the extra nautical mile and dressed like a pirate!

official web: www.ljsilvers.com

Final Thoughts

mateys! ‍ We’ve reached the end of our treasure map, and hopefully, your bellies are full of crispy fish and salty secrets! Remember, not everything on the high seas is what it seems, and Long John Silver’s secret menu is proof. You might just discover a new favorite, and who knows, maybe even become a legend yourself! Thanks for joining me on this delicious adventure, and happy sailing!